We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.
Last Updated on August 31, 2026 by Cate
Benjamin Moore Caldwell Green HC-124 is a rich, earthy green paint color with muted gray undertones that create a timeless, sophisticated look. Inspired by classic historic palettes, it strikes a beautiful balance between olive and forest green, making it feel bold without overwhelming a space. Caldwell Green is an excellent choice for cabinetry, accent walls, dining rooms, home offices, and exteriors, pairing beautifully with crisp white trim, warm wood tones, brass hardware, and natural stone.
STATS
- HUE FAMILY: Green – 46.972 7.157 158.186°
- LRV – 14.67
- COLOR COLLECTIONS: Historic Color Collection
The Historical Color Collection is
A collection of 191 time-honored hues comprises our most popular palette. Steeped in tradition, the refined, elegant colors of the Historical Collection deliver timeless color that can be used in traditional as well as contemporary spaces
Benjamin Moore
Caldwell Green has a low LRV because it is a darker color. So you can expect it to absorb more light than it reflects. By the way, if you are wondering what LRV is, I’ll explain what that means.
LRV, or Light Reflectance Value, is a measurement commonly used by design professionals. It measures how much light a surface reflects and absorbs. LRVs range from 0 -100, with 100 being pure white and 0 being absolute black. A great article to read to learn more about LRV is Light Reflectance Value: What Do Those Numbers Mean?
If you’re planning a painting project soon, these are the supplies worth adding to your cart first. A few good tools can seriously improve your results.
WHAT COLOR IS CALDWELL GREEN?
This is one of the easier questions to answer. BM Caldwell Green is a green paint color. Of course, ya’ll didn’t need me to tell you that, though. But if you want to dive a little deeper, Caldwell isn’t the typical green grass green you think of.
It has a softness to it that gives it an elegant appearance. It definitely is not a harsh or overbearing green. It’s more of a muted, grayed-down green. It looks beautiful as both an accent color and an overall wall color.
READ MORE: 14 AWESOME GREEN PAINT COLORS
WHAT UNDERTONES DOES CALDWELL GREEN HAVE?
Undertones are just perspective, so if you have imbalanced lighting, you may see Caldwell Green as having a blue-green undertone. But in daylight/balanced lighting, which is evenly balanced across all light wavelengths, it will appear as a grayed green.
I always suggest sampling a paint color in the room you plan to use it in. That is the only way to see how the light will affect the color.
IS CALDWELL GREEN A WARM OR COOL PAINT COLOR?
Depending on what you compare Caldwell Green to, it can look either cool or warm-toned.
A great way to tell whether a paint color is warm or cool is to compare it to another paint color.
For instance, let’s place Caldwell Green side by side with Benjamin Moore Misted Fern. You can clearly see how Misted Fern is more of a yellow-green and is the warmer of the two paint colors.
If you’re planning a painting project soon, these are the supplies worth adding to your cart first. A few good tools can seriously improve your results.
BEST TRIM COLOR FOR CALDWELL GREEN?
I have to say Caldwell Green looks absolutely amazing with a classic white trim color. You can use a bright white like BM Chantilly Lace for a clean, crisp look. Or you can use a color like BM White Dove or Swiss Coffee to add a touch of warmth. Either way looks beautiful.
READ MORE: THE BEST WHITE PAINT COLORS FOR TRIM
That said, painting your trim white isn’t your only option. Greens inherently look beautiful with wood tones. So, if you are adding trim to the space, consider keeping it the natural wood tone.
READ MORE: PAINT COLORS FOR HONEY OAK WOOD
You can also go with a monochromatic look and use Caldwell Green on both walls and trim. You can slightly change the trim’s look by choosing a different sheen or finish. This creates a subtle difference between the two.
WHERE TO USE BM CALDWELL GREEN?
KITCHEN CABINETS
Emma @rosecottage.dublin on Instagram used this gorgeous green on her kitchen cabinets, and all I can say is wow.
READ MORE: HOW TO PAINT KITCHEN CABINETS
How do you paint like a pro? By using the right tools and supplies! Check out the Ultimate Painting Tools List for everything you need to paint a room.
BATHROOM
You can use it as a wall color, or you can use it on paneling, as Christina @ourbouldlife on Instagram did.
I love that it adds a pop of color without being too much. It looks absolutely perfect in her bathroom.
BOARD AND BATTEN
I used Caldwell on the DIY board and batten I did in my guest bedroom, and boy, did it make all the difference. It truthfully transformed the room from boring to wow-worthy.
And it is also a beautiful paint color to go with brick.
IS CALDWELL GREEN HC-124 A GOOD EXTERIOR PAINT COLOR?
Yes, it is 100% a good paint color for the exterior of your home. It has enough depth to hold up to direct sunlight. Exterior paint colors tend to lighten in sunlight, so Caldwell Green is a good shade to combat that.
My home is painted Sherwin Williams Riverway, which is very similar in depth and it holds up beautifully in the direct sunlight. There is no doubt in my mind that Caldwell Green will do the same on the exterior.
Find a Little More Exterior Paint Color Inspiration:
Let’s talk about testing paint samples.
Before committing to a paint color, I highly recommend testing it in your own home first. Lighting can completely change how a color looks. I love using Samplize peel-and-stick samples because they’re mess-free and so much easier than buying sample pots.
I know I sound like a broken record, but testing paint samples is the only true way to see how a paint color will act in your home. That is why you absolutely must sample your paint colors!
SHERWIN WILLIAMS EQUIVALENT
Upon doing a little research, I found one color that is a pretty close Caldwell Green Sherwin Williams match, and that color is:
SW 9650 SUCCULENT Sherwin-Williams Emerald Designer Edition
- LRV: 14
- Hue Family: Green
- 47.871 5.413 155.420°
These two are not dupes. Yes, they are similar, but they are not the same paint color. Sherwin Williams Succulent is a hair darker and has a bit more gray in it.
They are both gorgeous colors, but they aren’t interchangeable.
If you’re considering color-matching between paint brands, I highly recommend buying a sample first. Sometimes, when you color-match between paint manufacturers, the colors don’t come out accurately. This is because each brand uses different formulas to create its paint colors.
The best option is to choose within the brand’s paint color lines. This way, you know what you are getting.
COORDINATING COLORS
Finding coordinating paint colors can sometimes be a challenge. But a few tips can help you figure out a color scheme.
The complementary color to green is red on the color wheel. This combination gives you options to play with tone and saturation. For example, explore soft reds or blush colors for a bold color palette.
For something a bit less lively, consider a monochromatic palette. Use different shades, tints, and tones of green to create a dynamic color scheme.
Some colors that work well with Caldwell are:
- White Dove
- Gray Sky 2131-70
- Soft Chamois
- Mayonnaise 2152-70
- Gray Owl OC-52
- Revere Pewter
- Silvery Moon 1604
- Castle Walls 1573
- Black
- Pale Oak
- Ballet White
- SW Caviar
CALDWELL GREEN VS CUSHING GREEN
- Cushing Green is a part of the Green-Yellow hue family – 49.177 9.913 144.291°
- Cushing Green has an LRV of 16.23
- Caldwell Green has a bit more gray in it.
- Cushing Green is a bit more yellow-green
CALDWELL GREEN VS SW PEWTER GREEN
- Sherwin Williams Pewter Green is from the Green-Yellow hue family 45.229 5.270 135.086°
- Pewter Green has an LRV of 12
- Pewter Green has more gray in it, making it a more muted green.
- Caldwell is more saturated between the two.
FINAL THOUGHTS
Benjamin Moore Caldwell Green HC-124 is an absolute beauty. I have to admit I am so smitten with this color. I don’t usually gravitate toward green paint colors, but there is something so appealing about Caldwell.
This muted, grayed-down gray is an excellent option to create both lively, dynamic, and calm, elegant atmospheres.
With green being on-trend right now, I say you cannot go wrong with Benjamin Moore Caldwell Green. It’s absolutely worth grabbing a sample.
If you like green, you may also be interested in Sherwin Williams Dried Thyme.
Are you looking for a way to keep track of all the paint colors in your home? Have you ever had to touch up some paint in your home and forgotten what the paint color was? It’s like you are playing the guessing game, what color, paint, finish, and brand? It’s completely frustrating! I have the perfect solution to keep your paint colors all in one place. My simple paint color tracker can keep you and your paint colors organized!
RECENT ARTICLES:
- Popular Cabinet Colors
- Natural Choice – A Great Neutral Color
- The Best Tiles- Farmhouse Style
- SW Dovetail- A Paint Color Review
- Dorian Gray SW Color Review
- Color Review – BM Beach Glass
- Kilim Beige Review
- SW Divine White
- Sherwin Williams Shoji White
- Sherwin Williams Sea Salt
- Coventry Gray BM- Color Review
- SW Reflection
