I may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post. Please click my Disclosure Policy to learn more
Ever wonder which gray paint reigns supreme — Sherwin Williams Repose Gray or Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter? I’ve tested, compared, and over-analyzed both (so you don’t have to). From undertones to lighting quirks, I’m breaking down which gray truly deserves a spot on your walls — with all the honest, paint-nerd details you actually need.
If you’ve ever found yourself standing in front of a wall of gray paint swatches whispering, “Why do they all look the same but not the same?” — you are not alone, my friend.
Today, we’re comparing two of the most popular gray paint colors of all time:
Sherwin Williams Repose Gray (SW 7015) and Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter (HC-172).
Both are tried-and-true, endlessly discussed, and very frequently used in homes all over. But that doesn’t mean they are both right for your home. So which one should you choose? Grab your wine, because we’re diving deep into undertones, lighting behavior, and real-life vibes.
Meet the Contenders
Sherwin Williams Repose Gray (SW 7015)
Repose Gray is a light to medium warm gray with an LRV of 58, which means it reflects a decent amount of light — perfect for keeping spaces feeling open and airy without washing them out.
It’s not too cool, not too warm — but still manages to pull a tiny bit of warmth, giving it a soft, approachable look.
Undertones: Slight violet and soft brown, with just a sprinkle of green when the lighting shifts (paint loves to keep us humble).
Best For:
- Open concept spaces
- Living rooms and bedrooms
- Homes with a lot of natural light
Pair It With:
Crisp whites like SW Pure White or moody accents like SW Iron Ore.
👉 Order Sherwin Williams Repose Gray peel-and-stick sample from Samplize
Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter (HC-172)
Revere Pewter is often called a “greige” rather than a true gray — and that’s absolutely right. It’s warmer, earthier, and cozier than Repose Gray. With an LRV of 55.05, it’s slightly darker but still comfortably light.
Undertones: Definite green-beige undertones that can shift depending on lighting — sometimes taupe, sometimes gray, sometimes both at once (Revere Pewter is basically the chameleon of paint colors).
Best For:
- Traditional or farmhouse-style homes
- Cozy rooms that need warmth
- North-facing spaces that need a little love
Pair It With:
BM White Dove for trim, or BM Chelsea Gray for contrast.
👉 Order Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter peel-and-stick sample from Samplize
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Sherwin Williams Repose Gray | Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter |
|---|---|---|
| LRV | 58 | 55.05 |
| Tone | Warm gray | Warm greige |
| Undertones | Violet-brown (sometimes green) | Green-beige |
| Mood | Modern, balanced, airy | Cozy, classic, earthy |
| Best Light | Natural daylight | Artificial or low natural light |
| Style Fit | Transitional, modern, coastal | Farmhouse, traditional, rustic |
💡 How Lighting Affects Each Shade
Lighting is the biggest reason people either fall in love with a color—or wonder if they accidentally painted with the wrong can.
Repose Gray in Different Light:
- South-facing rooms: Appears lighter, more neutral, and calm.
- Evening lighting: Takes on a warmer, almost greige cast.
- North-facing rooms: Can lean cooler or slightly violet-gray.
Revere Pewter in Different Light:
- South-facing rooms: Looks beautifully warm and inviting.
- North-facing rooms: Can flash a green or muddy undertone (sample before committing!).
- Warm artificial lighting: Brings out its soft, beige warmth.
Real-Life Feel: Repose Gray vs Revere Pewter
If you want your space to feel modern, crisp, and updated — Repose Gray is your girl. It’s a perfect neutral backdrop that plays nicely with black, white, and wood tones.
If you prefer cozy, timeless, and welcoming — Revere Pewter will never let you down. It has that warm hug of a color that feels lived-in and soft without being beige-beige.
I like to say:
- Repose Gray = your clean linen shirt.
- Revere Pewter = your favorite, worn-in sweater.
Designer Tips for Using These Grays
✅ Use Repose Gray :
- Homes with lots of natural light
- Modern or coastal spaces
- Open floor plans where you want color consistency
✅ Use Revere Pewter :
- Older homes or traditional architecture
- Rooms with less natural light
- Spaces where warmth and coziness are key
Bonus tip: If you’re unsure which one your space needs( even if you are not), sample both with Samplize peel-and-stick paint samples. Lighting, flooring, and decor tones will dramatically change how each gray behaves.
WANT TO SAMPLE PAINT COLORS THE EASY WAY?
TRY SAMPLIZE PEEL & STICK PAINT SAMPLES!
IT’S THE MESS & FUSS FREE WAY TO TEST PAINT COLORS.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Repose Gray lighter than Revere Pewter?
- Yes! With an LRV of 58, Repose Gray is slightly lighter and reflects more light than Revere Pewter (LRV 55.1).
Which color looks better in low-light rooms?
- Revere Pewter tends to feel warmer and more forgiving in low light. Repose Gray can go a bit cool or shadowy in dim spaces.
Can I use both colors in the same home?
- Absolutely. Many designers use Repose Gray for main living areas and Revere Pewter in bedrooms or hallways for subtle variation.
Are these colors outdated?
- Nope — they’re classics. While newer “greige” shades like Edgecomb Gray or Agreeable Gray have joined the chat, both Repose Gray and Revere Pewter still work beautifully in modern spaces. And as much as people say grays are out, they are still best sellers.
My Final Thoughts
If I had to pick? It really depends on your home’s personality.
- If your home has plenty of light and modern finishes, go with Repose Gray.
- If it leans traditional or needs warmth, Revere Pewter will give you that cozy, grounded feeling.
Both are timeless, versatile, and endlessly popular for good reason.
Just promise me one thing — always test before you paint. I’ve seen one too many homeowners fall victim to the “but it looked perfect on Pinterest” curse.
👉 Order Sherwin Williams Repose Gray peel-and-stick sample from Samplize
👉 Order Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter peel-and-stick sample from Samplize
Related Posts
- Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray vs Modern Gray
- The Best Sherwin Williams Gray Paint Colors
- Sherwin Williams Alpaca Review
I’m Cate. As a seasoned paint color consultant and former proprietor of the highly regarded painting company WOW 1 Day Painting in Bergen County, my journey in the world of design and home improvement has been a colorful one, quite literally. Nestled in the scenic landscapes of Northern New Jersey, I’ve cultivated a passion for transforming spaces through the power of paint, furniture restoration, and thoughtful home decor.