Benjamin Moore Wrought Iron Vs. Sherwin Williams Iron Ore

I may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post. Please click my Disclosure Policy to learn more

Discover the bold elegance of Benjamin Moore’s Wrought Iron and Sherwin Williams’ Iron Ore. Learn how these rich, versatile shades transform interiors and exteriors with their unique undertones and finishes.

“Black is modest and arrogant at the same time,” said Yohji Yamamoto. And the same can be said for deep, almost-black paint colors. They’re rich, bold, and moody—yet surprisingly versatile. Today, we’re talking about two crowd-favorites: Benjamin Moore Wrought Iron and Sherwin Williams Iron Ore. If you’ve been eyeing these colors for your next project, you’re in the right place. Let’s dive into the world of dramatic hues and break down the real differences between these two.

Key Takeaways:

• Color Palette Exploration: A detailed comparison of Benjamin Moore’s Wrought Iron and Sherwin Williams’ Iron Ore highlighting their unique properties.
• Design Considerations: Insight into how each paint’s undertones, finish, and light reflectance value affect home aesthetics.
• Practical Guidance: Tips on selection, application, and maintenance for durable, beautiful results in home renovation projects.

Wrought Iron: The Soft Charcoal That’s Almost-but-Not-Quite Black

Benjamin Moore’s Wrought Iron isn’t just black. It’s like black with a bit of mystery and elegance mixed in. Imagine charcoal with a soft side, or a dark slate that flirts with gray. It’s deep enough to bring drama but won’t make your space feel like a cave.

What’s great about Wrought Iron is how it changes with the light. It can feel softer and more welcoming in well-lit rooms, with just a whisper of warmth, almost like a muted navy or blue-gray in certain lighting. But come evening, it deepens into a rich, moody charcoal. This flexibility is what makes Wrought Iron perfect for anyone who wants depth without the intensity of true black.

Best For: Accent walls, cabinetry, or any room that wants to feel cozy but not claustrophobic.

Iron Ore: The Bold, Rich Charcoal

Now let’s talk about Sherwin Williams Iron Ore. If Wrought Iron is the mysterious one, Iron Ore is the bold, no-nonsense cousin. It’s a charcoal color that leans more toward true black but with a subtle warmth to keep it from feeling too stark. Iron Ore is rich, dark, and unapologetically bold.

In bright light, it shows its deep, inky undertones, which makes it a fantastic choice if you’re looking for a dramatic statement. But don’t be fooled into thinking it’s harsh—Iron Ore’s warm undertone adds just enough softness to keep it approachable. It’s strong, modern, and creates a sense of luxury that’s hard to beat.

Best For: Exterior doors, kitchen islands, or any feature that needs to pop with a strong, confident color.

Complementary colors For iron ore:

• Sherwin Williams Alabaster – A warm, creamy white that softens Iron Ore’s intensity.
• Accessible Beige – A timeless greige that adds warmth and complements Iron Ore’s earthy undertones.
• Evergreen Fog – A muted green that enhances Iron Ore’s grounding, natural vibe.
• Sea Salt – A soft, serene blue-green that offers a fresh, coastal contrast to Iron Ore.
• Drift of Mist – A light, neutral gray that adds an elegant, understated balance.

What’s the Real Difference BETWEEN IRON ORE AND WROUGHT IRON?

You might be thinking, “Okay, but aren’t they basically the same?” Well, not quite. Here’s how they differ: Both shades draw their essence from the natural elegance of iron but diverge significantly under differing illumination.

Benjamin Moore’s Wrought Iron is like the black blazer of paint—chic, timeless, and works with just about everything. It’s rich, deeply saturated, and instantly elevates any room or exterior. When the sunlight hits just right, you’ll notice subtle undertones sneaking through, blending beautifully with a range of color palettes. It’s the kind of color that screams you have your life together.

Now, on the other hand, Sherwin Williams’ Iron Ore brings a bit of a different vibe. It is more mysterious and a little moody. It tends to shift throughout the day in the light from morning to night, which gives off a bold, dynamic look. It’s been showing up on the facades of modern homes, turning heads with its powerful, dramatic presence.

These are two colors that bring their own unique energy. Whether you’re tackling a weekend DIY project or in full renovation mode, they both pack a punch. It’s all about how the light plays off the paint, the all-important Light Reflectance Value (LRV), and how they fit into your style, whether you lean traditional or love that modern, sleek look.

The Undertones Tell the Story

The real difference between these two comes down to undertones. They are the secret ingredient in paint that can transform the mood of a room. They’re those subtle hues hiding beneath the main color that can completely change the vibe of a space. Benjamin Moore’s Wrought Iron leans towards cool, with blue-based undertones that bring a refined, sophisticated feel.

On the flip side, Sherwin Williams’ Iron Ore has warmer, earthy undertones that give off a cozy, welcoming vibe. The way these colors react to light is key. Wrought Iron creates a serene atmosphere in bright spaces, while Iron Ore wraps a room in warmth.

Understanding these subtleties helps you choose the paint that fits your vision, ensuring it works beautifully with your lighting and decor.

How to Choose: Wrought Iron or Iron Ore?

So, which one should you choose? Here’s the million-dollar question. If you’re after a color that brings depth but with a touch of softness, Benjamin Moore Wrought Iron will be your best friend. It’s adaptable, elegant, and less harsh than a true black.

But if you want something a bit bolder and warmer and want a color that says, “I’m here to make an impact,” go with Sherwin Williams Iron Ore. It’s bold, dramatic, and perfect for making architectural features or focal points pop. It’s a paint color that is reasonably comfortable in a rustic farmhouse or a contemporary loft.

Pro Tip: Always Test Your Paint

Before you fall head over heels for one of these moody hues, do yourself a favor: test them out. Grab some samples, throw them on a few walls, and see how the colors shift throughout the day. You might love how Wrought Iron feels in the morning light but prefer Iron Ore’s boldness at night. Don’t rush this process! Let the paint sit with you for a bit (literally).

THE BEST WAY TO SAMPLE

RECAP – WROUGHT IRON VS IRON ORE

• Undertones: Wrought Iron leans cooler, with subtle gray and blue undertones, giving it that soft, sophisticated feel. Iron Ore, meanwhile, has a warmer undertone, which adds a touch of depth and richness.
• Light Reflectance Value (LRV): If you’re not familiar with LRV, think of it as how much light a paint color reflects. Wrought Iron has a slightly higher LRV (6.16), which means it reflects a bit more light and can appear lighter in certain spaces. Iron Ore’s LRV is 6, so it’s just a smidge darker. But in darker rooms? Iron Ore will look more intense and bold.
• Versatility: Wrought Iron is like a chameleon—it shifts and adapts to different styles and spaces, making it perfect for modern, traditional, or transitional homes. Iron Ore, on the other hand, is more at home in modern, industrial, or contemporary designs. It’s a bold, statement-making color that doesn’t like to play second fiddle.

Final Thoughts

At the end of the day, both Benjamin Moore Wrought Iron and Sherwin Williams Iron Ore are stunning choices if you’re after that deep, dark color with a touch of personality. The key is to know what you need from a paint color. Is it moody sophistication or bold warmth? They both offer richness and sophistication but in slightly different ways.

The choice is yours, but one thing is for sure—both colors are stunning, versatile, and ready to elevate any space you splash them on. Either way, you’ll be rocking one seriously stylish space!

So go ahead! Pick up those Samplize Peel & Stick paint samples, slap them up, and let your walls do the talking!