Agreeable Gray vs Revere Pewter

I may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post. Please click my Disclosure Policy to learn more

Agreeable Gray and Revere Pewter are both warm neutral paint colors, but they behave very differently. Agreeable Gray is lighter, more flexible, and better for open-concept homes, while Revere Pewter is warmer, deeper, and ideal for traditional spaces with good natural light.

If you’ve ever found yourself staring at paint samples thinking, “ Why are there SO many greiges and why do they all look the same until they’re on my wall? — welcome. You’re in good company.

Today, we’re putting two of the most Googled, most sampled, most emotionally debated neutral paint colors head-to-head:

• Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray (SW 7029)
• Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter (HC-172)

I’ve used both. I’ve tested both. I’ve watched them behave beautifully… and sometimes misbehave terribly depending on lighting. So let’s break this down the right way — with some helpful insider tips to help you decide if either of these colors will work for you.

Quick Overview: Agreeable Gray vs Revere Pewter

Paint Color	Brand	Undertone Family	LRV	Overall Vibe
Agreeable Gray	Sherwin Williams	Warm greige (soft taupe)	60	Light, airy, flexible
Revere Pewter	Benjamin Moore	Warm gray-beige	55.05	Rich, grounded, classic

Bottom line: Agreeable Gray is lighter and more neutral-flexible. Revere Pewter is deeper and warmer with more personality.

Agreeable Gray (SW 7029): The Crowd-Pleaser

Ah yes, Agreeable Gray — the Switzerland of paint colors. Neutral. Polite. Gets along with everyone.

Undertones

Agreeable Gray is a warm greige with subtle taupe and beige undertones. It can pick up a whisper of green in certain lighting, but it’s usually very well-behaved.

What it doesn’t do:

• Go icy
• Flash purple
• Suddenly turn beige out of nowhere

That reliability is exactly why it’s so popular.

LRV (Light Reflectance Value)

• LRV: 60

This puts Agreeable Gray solidly in the light-neutral category. It reflects enough light to keep rooms bright without feeling stark.

Best Rooms for Agreeable Gray

• Open-concept homes
• Living rooms
• Hallways and staircases
• Homes with mixed warm + cool finishes

Agreeable Gray is especially good if you’re working with:

• Warm wood floors
• Stainless steel
• Mixed metal finishes

Pros

• Extremely versatile
• Works in many lighting situations
• Great resale color
• Easy to coordinate with trim and accents

Cons

• Can feel a little too safe
• May read flat in low-light rooms
• Not ideal if you want strong character

Cate’s take: If neutrals had a first-born child who followed all the rules, this would be it. And honestly? Sometimes that’s exactly what you want.

Before you commit, do yourself a favor and test both colors in your own home. Peel-and-stick samples let you see how Agreeable Gray and Revere Pewter actually look in your lighting — without the mess, cost, or regret of repainting. See Agreeable Gray & Revere Pewter in Your Home

Revere Pewter (HC-172): The Moody Classic

Revere Pewter is that effortlessly stylish friend who always looks put together but never tries too hard.

Undertones

Revere Pewter is a warm gray-beige with noticeable brown and taupe undertones. It leans warmer than Agreeable Gray and feels more traditional.

This color loves:

• Warm light
• Natural stone
• Creamy whites

LRV (Light Reflectance Value)

• LRV: 55.05

Revere Pewter is a touch darker, which gives it more depth and richness — but it also means lighting matters more.

Best Rooms for Revere Pewter

• Dining rooms
• Offices
• Family rooms
• Homes with warm finishes

It shines in spaces with:

• Southern or western exposure
• Traditional or transitional style
• Warm trim colors

Pros

• Sophisticated and timeless
• Adds depth and warmth
• Beautiful with natural materials

Cons

• Can feel heavy in dark rooms
• Less forgiving in cool lighting
• Not as open-concept-friendly

Cate’s take: This is the neutral you choose when you want your house to feel expensive without being trendy.

When two neutrals are this close, seeing them side by side makes all the difference. I always recommend peel-and-stick samples so you can compare colors on multiple walls and at different times of day — it’s how I make confident color decisions. Compare These Colors Side by Side Before You Paint

Agreeable Gray vs Revere Pewter: Side-by-Side Comparison

Lighting Sensitivity

• Agreeable Gray: More adaptable across different exposures
• Revere Pewter: Best in rooms with good natural light

Warmth Level

• Agreeable Gray: Light warm-neutral
• Revere Pewter: Noticeably warmer and deeper

Style Match

• Agreeable Gray: Modern, transitional, builder-friendly
• Revere Pewter: Traditional, classic, cozy

Open Concept Homes

• Agreeable Gray: Winner 🏆
• Revere Pewter: Better for defined spaces

Trim Pairings That Work

Best Whites for Agreeable Gray

• Sherwin Williams Pure White
• Sherwin Williams Alabaster

Best Whites for Revere Pewter

• Benjamin Moore White Dove
• Benjamin Moore Simply White

Pro tip: Avoid bright, cool whites with Revere Pewter — they’ll make it look muddy.

FAQs: Agreeable Gray vs Revere Pewter

Is Agreeable Gray or Revere Pewter better for resale?

Agreeable Gray wins here. It’s lighter, safer, and more universally appealing to buyers.

Which one works better with gray floors?

Agreeable Gray. Revere Pewter can clash with cool-toned grays. Grab samples to see for yourself!

Can I use Revere Pewter in a small room?

Yes — but only if you have good lighting. Otherwise, it can feel heavy.

Is Agreeable Gray too beige?

No, but it is warm. If you want a true gray, neither of these is your color.

Try Before You Commit (Seriously, Please Do This)

Both of these colors are notorious for looking very different depending on light and surrounding finishes.

I always recommend:

• Peel-and-stick samples
• Testing on multiple walls
• Watching them throughout the day

Your walls deserve better than guesswork.

Final Verdict: Which One Should You Choose?

Choose Agreeable Gray (Sample It) if you want:

• Light and flexible
• Open-concept friendly
• Minimal drama

Choose Revere Pewter (Sample It) if you want:

• Warm and rich
• Classic and timeless
• A little more personality

Neither is “better” — they just serve different purposes. And when you choose the right one for your home? Magic.

If you’re still stuck, this is exactly what I help with in my color consultations. Paint decisions are emotional — and your walls shouldn’t stress you out.

Related Paint Color Comparisons You’ll Love:

• Natural Linen vs Accessible Beige
• Revere Pewter vs Repose Gray
• Agreeable Gray vs Worldly Gray
• Best Sherwin Williams Warm Neutral Paint Colors
• Best Benjamin Moore Neutral Paint Colors

Not sure which one will work in your home? I highly recommend trying Samplize peel-and-stick paint samples first so you can see how each color looks in your lighting—no mess, no guesswork.