Edgecomb Gray vs Revere Pewter

I may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post. Please click my Disclosure Policy to learn more

Edgecomb Gray and Revere Pewter are both warm neutral paint colors, but they behave differently. Edgecomb Gray is lighter and softer, making it better for open-concept homes, while Revere Pewter is deeper and warmer, ideal for traditional spaces with good natural light.

Edgecomb Gray and Revere Pewter are two paint colors that can make people a bit crazy. These two Benjamin Moore favorites are often lumped together as “safe greige neutrals”… but they behave very differently once they’re on the wall. I’ve used both in real homes, and lighting can make one feel creamy and cozy, while the other suddenly reads darker and moodier.

Let me help clear up some questions (and without the paint-chip lies).

Quick Overview: Edgecomb Gray vs Revere Pewter

Paint Color	Brand	Undertone Family	LRV	Overall Vibe
Edgecomb Gray (HC-173)	Benjamin Moore	Warm greige with subtle taupe	63.88	Soft, airy, flexible
Revere Pewter (HC-172)	Benjamin Moore	Warm greige with beige/taupe	55.05	Classic, grounded, cozy

Quick takeaway: Edgecomb Gray is lighter and more forgiving. Revere Pewter is deeper and adds more contrast.

Edgecomb Gray (HC-173): Light, Soft & Open-Concept Friendly

Edgecomb Gray is one of my go-to “I want warm but not beige” colors. It’s airy without being stark and reads soft in most lighting.

Undertones:

Warm greige with a subtle taupe influence. It avoids yellow and doesn’t swing cold unless paired with very cool whites.

LRV:

• 63 — reflects a lot of light, which helps rooms feel open.

Best Rooms:

• Open-concept living areas
• Hallways & stairwells
• Basements with some natural light

Pros

• Brightens spaces
• Flexible with mixed lighting
• Easy whole-house neutral

Cons

• Can feel too light in very large rooms
• Needs warm trim to avoid looking washed out

Cate’s take: This is the color I use when someone wants “warm and modern” without committing to beige.

Revere Pewter (HC-172): Deeper, Cozier & More Traditional

Revere Pewter is a classic for a reason — it’s richer and adds visual weight to a space. Gorgeous when the lighting is right.

UNDERTONES:

Warm greige with beige/taupe undertones. It reads warmer than Edgecomb Gray and can feel cozy (or heavy) depending on light.

LRV:

• 55 — noticeably deeper, absorbs more light.

Best Rooms:

• Dining rooms
• Family rooms
• Bedrooms with good natural light

Pros

• Adds depth and contrast
• Feels timeless and traditional
• Pairs beautifully with warm woods

Cons

• Can look heavy in dark rooms
• Needs adequate lighting to shine

Cate’s take: This is the one I choose when a room needs grounding and warmth, not just “neutral.”+

Edgecomb Gray vs Revere Pewter: Side-by-Side

Lighting Sensitivity

• Edgecomb Gray: More forgiving
• Revere Pewter: Needs good light

Warmth Level

• Edgecomb Gray: Soft warm neutral
• Revere Pewter: Warmer and cozier

Best for Open Concept

• Edgecomb Gray: Winner 🏆
• Revere Pewter: Better for defined rooms

Style Match

• Edgecomb Gray: Transitional/modern
• Revere Pewter: Traditional/classic

Trim Pairings That Actually Work

Best Whites for Edgecomb Gray

• BM White Dove
• BM Simply White

Best Whites for Revere Pewter

• BM White Dove
• BM Swiss Coffee

Avoid icy, bluish, cool whites — they’ll make both colors look muddy.

People Also Ask: Edgecomb Gray vs Revere Pewter

Is Edgecomb Gray lighter than Revere Pewter?
Yes. Edgecomb Gray (LRV 63) is lighter and reflects more light than Revere Pewter (LRV 55).

Which is better for open-concept homes?
Edgecomb Gray adapts better to changing light across connected spaces.

Do these colors work with wood floors?
Both do, but Revere Pewter pairs especially well with medium-to-dark woods.

Is Revere Pewter too dark for small rooms?
It can be if the room lacks natural or layered lighting.

Try Before You Commit (Highly Recommended)

These two colors can look very different depending on lighting and surrounding finishes.

I always recommend peel-and-stick samples so you can:

• See undertones in your own lighting
• Compare them side by side
• Avoid repaint regret

Final Verdict: Which One Should You Choose?

Choose Edgecomb Gray if you want:

• A lighter, brighter neutral
• Open-concept flexibility
• A warm color that still feels modern

Choose Revere Pewter if you want:

• More depth and contrast
• A classic, cozy feel
• Warmth that grounds a room

Both are fantastic. The right choice depends on your lighting and how much visual weight your space needs.

If you’re still torn, seeing them side by side makes the choice obvious.

RECENT POSTS YOU MAY ENJOY

• PPG Knight’s Armor PPG1001-6
• PPG Sharkskin Paint Review (PPG1025-4)
• PPG Ghost Writer PPG1007-3
• Toasted Almond PPG1097-3 Review
• Farm Fresh PPG1129-5